WARNING:We have detected your browser is out of date. For both performance, security and a better web experience you should keep up to date to avoid viruses, malware, hijacking and stay on top of compatibility features.
WNS Column: Why WWE Should NOT Give Up on Roman Reigns
Posted By: Caylon Knox on Jul 01, 2016
Long before Roman Reigns' recent suspension from WWE for violating their Wellness Policy, there's been a lot of debate as to what Roman's future in WWE will look like and whether or not WWE should just give up on him as a World Champion/main event caliber performer. For the fans who dislike Reigns, his recent suspension will be another big reason to criticize him and boo him out of the building. Perhaps WWE can capitalize on this.
Should WWE give up on Roman Reigns as far as being the next top babyface along the lines of John Cena, The Rock, "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, Hulk Hogan, etc.? I would say yes. Most definitely, yes. The WWE Universe has made it crystal clear over the past year that they aren't buying Roman Reigns as the next top babyface in the company. But that certainly doesn't mean that WWE should give up on Reigns as a character or a performer. Quite the contrary, they should just completely give in to how the fans want to react to Roman, and let him be one of the best heels that the company has seen in years.
Roman gets a lot of boos from the audience, but any reaction is better than no reaction at all. If nobody cared about him at all, he would receive a dead-silent reaction instead of the deafening boos that he usually seems to receive. However, nobody can deny that his matches, especially his high-profile main event matches, are downright entertaining to watch. Say what you want about his imperfections on the microphone, but Roman Reigns has absolutely demonstrated time and time again that he can flat out get it done in the ring. Whether you're rooting for Reigns or against him, the fact of the matter is that his matches are just plain fun to watch. Reigns is more than capable of having fast-paced, hard-hitting, back-and-forth matches that will keep the fans on the edge of their seats.
Personally, I don't really like Reigns as a babyface at all. I like him much better as a heel. I loved his work when he was the silent, badass enforcer for The Shield. I'm starting to like him a lot more again now that he slowly, slowly seems to be transitioning back into a full-fledged heel.
Despite WWE's fantasies about having Roman be the "squeaky clean, good guy" face of the company, it seems as though Roman is destined to achieve greater success as a heel character. Many Superstars nowadays seem to be much better at playing a heel than a babyface, and Roman Reigns is no exception. In fact, when asked if they prefer being a babyface or a heel, most wrestlers will often say that it's both easier and a lot more fun to play a heel. If the WWE Universe wants Roman Reigns to be a heel, then so be it.
Why should WWE give up on Reigns at this point? They've invested so much time and effort into trying to establish him as a main eventer. As far as establishing Reigns as a "top guy" on the roster, they've been successful. Roman Reigns has become a household name and the fans are well aware of who he is and the great Samoan Dynasty that he comes from. As far as making him a likable babyface, indeed, that experiment has been a complete and utter failure. But again, this certainly does not mean that WWE should just throw in the towel and give up on him.
Look at Randy Orton. Orton was a heel for a few years as part of Evolution, but then he became a babyface after winning the World Heavyweight Championship at SummerSlam 2004 and becoming the youngest World Champion in WWE history. But the babyface Orton experiment only lasted for a short time, and he turned back into a heel again leading up to his match against The Undertaker at WrestleMania 21. Orton was one of the top heels in the company for over five years from 2005 until 2010, when he started feuding with his former Legacy proteges Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase Jr. When Legacy split up, the fans starting cheering for Orton as he proceeded to take the young rookies to school and defeated them both in convincing fashion at WrestleMania 26. Throughout 2010, Orton became the most popular Superstar on the roster as he was RKO'ing everybody left and right and picking up clean victories over many of WWE's top Superstars.
Why couldn't the same thing happen with Roman Reigns? Let him get himself over as a top heel for a few years until the fans start to like and respect him more. Eventually, the fans will realize - and perhaps begrudgingly admit - that Reigns has a true passion for his career and really is a stellar performer in the ring. He could slowly win more and more of the fans over as a heel until eventually they'll be cheering for him like he's a babyface when he's still supposed to be the heel. That's when WWE could try to turn him into a full-fledged babyface again.
Imagine this: Reigns is a top heel for a few years and is slowly starting to get more and more cheers from the fans. It gets to the point where he's getting the cheers that his babyface opponents are supposed to be getting. WWE holds off on turning him back into a full-fledged babyface. They drag it out as long as they can and do some kind of a storyline where Reigns seems to be on the fence about what he wants to do and who he wants to align himself with. Reigns gets screwed over somehow and completely snaps and starts destroying everybody and everything in sight, very similar to what we saw at the Tables, Ladders & Chairs pay-per-view in December of 2015. Reigns went absolutely psychotic after losing to Sheamus and the fans LOVED it. After years of being a hated villain, Reigns could potentially become the huge babyface star that WWE has always wanted him to be.
The thing is though, as I mentioned before, Reigns just seems to be better at playing a heel than a babyface. Even if WWE were to plan out a beautiful storyline like that and execute it to perfection, Reigns would probably have a certain shelf life as a babyface before they would need to turn him heel once again. Going back to Randy Orton, this is exactly what we've seen with Orton over the past few years. Every so often he'll switch sides in order to keep his character from going stale, but Orton doesn't switch too much like Big Show, Mark Henry, and Kane. Those three switch sides so often that anymore it's almost impossible to know whether they're a heel or a babyface at any given time. Big Show has even publicly stated in interviews that he doesn't even know whether he's a heel or babyface half of the time. WWE has been careful not to switch Orton too many times, and they would need to treat Roman with that same kind of care.
But even if Reigns can only be a top babyface for a short time, he could be a great babyface while it lasts. WWE could ride it out for as long as they can before the fans would eventually get sick of him as a babyface. Then, logically, the next thing to do would be to turn him back into a heel again. Just like Randy Orton.
Time will tell how WWE handles Roman Reigns throughout the remainder of 2016 and beyond. But if you really think about it, there's no big reason why they should just kill his push dead in the water. They should absolutely give up on him as a babyface, but they should not give up on him as a top guy on the roster. Reigns desperately needs to just be an all-out heel and remain a heel for a number of years until the fans finally warm up to him. His future can still be incredibly bright and he can still headline a lot of pay-per-views and win a lot of championships. He just can't do it as the babyface that WWE wants him to be. Roman Reigns should be the top heel in the company, plain and simple. Let the fans hate his guts for a few years, and let them pay money to hopefully see him lose to his more popular adversaries. The sky would be the limit for a heel Roman Reigns.
May 06 - It's finally back! The Dark Side of the Ring season three premiere will air tonight on Vice TV. The season will open with a two-hour documentary on the late Brian Pillman. Dark Side of the Ring is V[...]
May 06 - Bully Ray is not happy with AEW. The former IMPACT world champion was not pleased with how Kenny Omega treated the belt on last night's AEW Dynamite. Omega entered his match wearing the AEW World tit[...]
May 06 - As previously reported last night, the first hour of AEW Dynamite: Blood & Guts was pre-recorded weeks ago. The live crowd in attendance for the Blood & Guts match was shown the first hour on[...]
Update On AEW Pay-Per-Views Getting An Intermission During a recent episode of Busted Open Radio, AEW President Tony Khan mentioned that AEW pay-per-views could have intermissions inserted in the future. At the time he said, "We have great and we coul[...]
May 06 - During a recent episode of Busted Open Radio, AEW President Tony Khan mentioned that AEW pay-per-views could have intermissions inserted in the future. At the time he said, "We have great and we coul[...]
May 06 - Following last night’s AEW Dynamite Tony Schiavone was involved in a post-show breakdown, and he was asked a number of questions, including the possibility of AEW signing Daniel Bryan and Samoa [...]
May 06 - Kalisto was one of 10 wrestlers to be released by WWE last month. Currently, he has a 90-day non-compete clause which means he will not be able to wrestle for any other promotion until the middle of [...]
NJPW To Broadcast Two Big Events On FITE TV New Japan Pro Wrestling issued the following press release: This May, Wrestle Grand Slam is set to deliver a pair of home run events to spectacular baseball stadiums in Yokohama and Tokyo. On May 15,[...]
May 06 - New Japan Pro Wrestling issued the following press release: This May, Wrestle Grand Slam is set to deliver a pair of home run events to spectacular baseball stadiums in Yokohama and Tokyo. On May 15,[...]
May 06 - SirusXM host and former political candidate Howard Stern was recently interviewed by the NY Daily News and believes that Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson running for President would not be a good idea. John[...]
May 06 - Wednesday's first-ever Blood & Guts match on AEW Dynamite was a bloody affair and despite being given the second hour of the broadcast on TNT had to be cut down. It was noted by Dave Meltzer on t[...]
Daniel Bryan Knew He Was Leaving WWE For A While During the latest episode of Wrestling Observer Radio, the hot topic was Daniel Bryan's contract with WWE expiring. Dave Meltzer offered some insight into what went down with Bryan and the fact he kne[...]
May 06 - During the latest episode of Wrestling Observer Radio, the hot topic was Daniel Bryan's contract with WWE expiring. Dave Meltzer offered some insight into what went down with Bryan and the fact he kne[...]
May 06 - On the most recent episode of the House of Hardcore podcast, pro-wrestling veteran Tommy Dreamer discussed recently testing positive for COVID-19 and the symptoms he experienced. "This is day 24 sinc[...]
May 06 - In the late 90s, Goldberg was one of WCW's hottest names and according to WWE Hall Of Famer Jim Ross, WWE Chairman and CEO Vince McMahon wanted him. During the latest edition of the Grilling JR podca[...]
May 06 - In 2006, the relationship between Kurt Angle and WWE was at an all-time low. After seven years with the company, the Olympic gold medallist decided to leave and within two months of his departure, he [...]
Azteca Underground's "El Jefe" Has Arrived! On this week's MLW Fusion, the owner of Azteca Underground was revealed. Dario Cueto revealed himself as the organization’s El Jefe. It all went down after Salina de la Renta was taken to Boyle[...]
May 05 - On this week's MLW Fusion, the owner of Azteca Underground was revealed. Dario Cueto revealed himself as the organization’s El Jefe. It all went down after Salina de la Renta was taken to Boyle[...]
May 05 - As seen on this week’s episode of AEW Dynamite, MJF pushed Chris Jericho off the top of the Blood & Guts cage down onto the stage area. His fall was broken by crash pads to protect a 50-yea[...]
May 05 - During tonight's AEW Dynamite the company held their first-ever Blood & Guts match, and bloody it was! The show ended in controversial fishing with MJF standing tall after winning the match for h[...]
May 05 - During tonight’s AEW Blood and Guts Dynamite special on TNT, SCU defeated the Varsity Blondes, The Acclaimed, and Jurassic Express. Their win has earned them a tag team title match against the [...]
May 05 - Myron Reed has become the two-time holder of the MLW World Middleweight Champion after defeating Lio Rush on tonight’s season finale of MLW Fusion. Reed scored the big win with Captain Crunch f[...]
MLW Announces An Open Draft For Next Week During the season finale of MLW Fusion, it was announced that MLW will begin an Open Draft starting next week. This draft is open to all free agents and athletes who are eligible to have a working re[...]
May 05 - During the season finale of MLW Fusion, it was announced that MLW will begin an Open Draft starting next week. This draft is open to all free agents and athletes who are eligible to have a working re[...]
May 05 - AEW Women’s World Champion Hikaru Shida will go up against Britt Baker at AEW Double or Nothing on May 30 at Daily’s Place in Jacksonville, Florida. This is the first official match for A[...]
May 05 - The first hour of tonight's AEW Dynamite on TNT was actually pre-taped. Fans in attendance for tonight's show in Daily's Place, Jacksonville, FL noted the matches that aired during the first ho[...]
May 05 - AEW’s Blood & Guts main event will air for the entiere second hour of tonight’s Dynamite episode on TNT. The match will feature The Inner Circle (Chris Jericho, Jake Hager, Sammy Guev[...]
WWE Champion Bobby Lashley And Batista Met Up Today WWE Champion Bobby Lashley met up with WWE Champion Batista outside a Steakhouse in Tampa, Florida today. The current WWE Champ posted a number of photos with The Animal, with the caption: "So good [...]
May 05 - WWE Champion Bobby Lashley met up with WWE Champion Batista outside a Steakhouse in Tampa, Florida today. The current WWE Champ posted a number of photos with The Animal, with the caption: "So good [...]
May 05 - During an interview with Entrepreneur.com, AEW President Tony Khan discussed how the AEW product compares to WWE and the differences which he believes make AEW more in tune with the audience. "There&[...]