WARNING: We have detected your browser is out of date. For both performance, security and a better web experience you should keep up to date to avoid viruses, malware, hijacking and stay on top of compatibility features.
 
RSS Feed

Dave Meltzer On WWE's "Dishonest" Montreal Screwjob Documentary

Posted By: Ben Kerin on Sep 17, 2014

Dave Meltzer On WWE's "Dishonest" Montreal Screwjob Documentary

Dave Meltzer of The Wrestling Observer Newsletter discussed in-depth the discrepancies between the recent WWE Network Monday Night War episode which focused on Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels and the Montreal Screwjob in 1997 to his account what actually happened during that controversial period.

Melter believes WWE have not only been bias but dishonest in their approach to the retelling of this story. 

"I saw the Monday Night War episode on Bret Hart that aired on 9/16 just because I wanted to see how the thing was portrayed. The funny thing is the real story is far more interesting than the version portrayed. They wanted to portray it simply as Bret Hart was leaving and refused to do the job on the way out, and Vince did what he had to do. In time, that simplistic version has taken over as the reality, since it’s easy to digest and paints McMahon as completely in the right.

I’d seen other episodes and as someone who lived through it and through the entire evolution of the business, the entire narrative of evil Ted vs. undermanned but smarter Vince was annoying just because in a free enterprise world, evil Ted did nothing Vince didn’t do, and really did far less in the 80s. Plus, the overemphasis on Ted Turner, who may have spent five minutes a year thinking about the wrestling business, and underplaying of Eric Bischoff has, if anything, gotten even worse over time. If Turner really wanted to beat Vince McMahon as bad as they said, he could have done so in 1989 by simply raiding every top star Vince had when their deals were up. In reality, WCW was put on a small budget and told to make money.

Every idea, from going live in prime time, or late going head-to-head, were things Jim Herd and Bill Watts wanted to do and were turned down. Their jobs were to balance the budget, and keep in mind, this was a budget where zero revenue was listed for television rights fees, which meant they had to break even on house shows, merch and PPV alone. Watts even came close to pulling it off, but alienated the talent in doing so with all the budget slashing. If they were given in the budget television rights fees of even $8 million a year, Herd would have run a profitable company and Watts would have had an even more profitable company.

Bischoff was given an open checkbook, and the green light to really have a chance to win and all the weapons to do so. He failed because he presented a product that turned off much of his audience, and because he had no understanding that in wrestling, the present doesn’t last forever and playing a pat hand for too long is death. Or at least was in the old business, which didn’t have the guaranteed cushion on television money. Today, the old rules don’t apply.

In addition, every episode has so much repeated material. I can see liking it if you didn’t live through it and were willing to accept a babyface vs. heel portrait of a wrestling war instead of the reality where both sides were trying to cut the others’ throats constantly and one side eventually collapsed because they didn’t prepare for any future and lost complete touch with their fan base, while the other was in touch with theirs.

They attempted to not bury Hart personally, because he’s one of the legends they bring out when needed. But they left out all the details that would give one a perspective of what really happened. They talked about the Michaels’ knee injury and told the story that Hart thought Michaels created the fake knee injury to avoid dropping the title to him. In actuality, Michaels was booked to lose to Sycho Sid on a live TV special in Lowell, MA (which was also the beginning of the Dwayne Johnson backlash when they had him beat HHH for the IC title less than three months after his debut and it was way early and the fans turned on him after being completely behind him as the new young star up to that point), not Hart. He showed up that day, and claimed a career ending knee injury and gave the lost my smile promo and handed Vince the belt and refused to even lose in his “last career match.”

Of course, he was back two months later, without having surgery, and as good as ever. What he also missed was WrestleMania, where he was going to lose to Hart, but the title match by that point was Undertaker beating Sid. Ratings were down and Vince at the time blamed it on pushing smaller guys, so he went with the big guys in the title match, and Mania that year did 237,000 buys. Of course, it also started the turnaround since the Hart vs. Austin I Quit match that turned Austin babyface was on that show.

In the discussion of Montreal, not one talking head was balanced. They were all the idea that Hart was going to leave without dropping the title, which was never the case. McMahon portrayed it as if he was doing Hart a favor and actually swerving Bischoff in allowing Hart to go. And McMahon was the catalyst when he told Hart to see if he could get the Bischoff deal. The simple part of the story is Hart was vocally negative about the direction of the company, and Hart and Michaels had gotten toxic.

Hart was also making $1.5 million a year, about double Undertaker and Michaels and even more than that compared to Austin. Times were still tough for WWF, although they were just starting to break even due to a change in PPV philosophy and upping the price. But at the time, McMahon felt that if Hart was around at $1.5 million a year, that Undertaker, Michaels and eventually Austin would want the same guarantee. McMahon also saw that Hart wasn’t the future. Whether at that point he thought the future was Michaels, or Austin, isn’t clear, although when he laid out booking scenarios to Hart if he were to stay, by that point it was clear he felt it was Austin. Hart got a better deal, even though he didn’t want it because he had no faith in WCW. In hindsight, he was right about that.

But they never mentioned that the contract gave Hart the power that in the last 30 days, it was not a boss/employee relationship, but a collaboration, the creative control clause was that both sides had to agree on all booking. This is where the Paul Heyman talking head of “Vince is the boss,” falls apart, because it was in the contract both had to agree. And it’s not like Heyman, in running a company, didn’t constantly have to negotiate finishes to his talent. That’s just how the business was in that era. It had its good and bad points. It was harder to book shows, but the superstars had an easier time staying larger than life because they protected themselves on finishes, particularly, on television.

Vince wanted Hart to lose the title in Montreal to Michaels. Hart wanted to lose to Austin in the U.S. Neither would agree. Lawyers were involved. They came up with one scenario after another to get Hart to lose to Michaels in Montreal, and he said that with the nature of the feud with Michaels, he was not going to go into Montreal without the belt and would lose the belt outside of Canada. He even agreed to lose to Steve Lombardi in Madison Square Garden, which was a week later. The part that Vince Russo in his talking head piece didn’t mention, and Paul Levesque of course didn’t mention, was that Vince came up with a solution, or at least he thought, where Hart would beat Michaels clean in Montreal and then Hart would drop it clean to Michaels at the following PPV. It was only after Michaels refused that scenario (Michaels never talked about it publicly until once, in an interview with Rob Feinstein, the question was thrown at him, he acted stunned, but admitted that it happened and that HHH insisted to him that he was not to lose to Hart).

At that point, Vince was in a bad position because he’d given Hart a scenario he’d agreed to, and then Michaels nixed it. Hart knew that, which only made him more adamant about not losing to Michaels. The compromise, and this was the scenario the night before that McMahon presented in the production meeting, and that Hart had agreed to, was that there would be a non-finish in Montreal, and on the next PPV, there would be a four-way with Michaels, Hart, Undertaker and Ken Shamrock. It would be an elimination match, so Hart would lose cleanly in his last night in, to either Undertaker or Shamrock. Hart had great respect for Undertaker, and Hart personally recruited Shamrock to WWF. The point being is that Hart considered Shamrock almost a protégé, since Shamrock even trained in Calgary for his WWF debut in Hart’s camp under Leo Burke and he’d have had no problems losing to either one on the way out. Given who the two were, that should have been obvious, but tensions were high and I don’t know that anybody was truly thinking straight. Whoever beat Hart for the fall would have then lost the final fall clean to Michaels. Vince gets Michaels as champion, which was important because Michaels was absolutely the best guy to hold the belt to drop it to Austin at Mania the next year, since Austin was surpassing both Hart and Michaels as the top guy by that time.

The main reason Hart had the problem with Michaels is that when Vince had first told Hart the long-term plan was to get the title to Michaels, which he didn’t oppose at first, and Hart told Michaels he was fine losing to him, Michaels came back and said he was happy he said it but that he wasn’t willing if asked, to return the favor. It’s hard to believe he said that, but he actually said it on two different occasions. This came shortly after Michaels had gotten the finish of the European title match with Davey Boy Smith changed in a U.K. match, as Smith was going to beat Michaels to retain his title. The office booked it that way largely to prove to the locker room Michaels would lose a big match because so many guys were mad, because Michaels had publicly talked in the locker room about how he doesn’t do jobs. Smith had then dedicated the match on television to his sister, who was dying of cancer. Then, the night of the show, they came to Smith and said that they were switching the title, with the idea of building a huge rematch on a U.K. only PPV early the next year where he’d beat Michaels. This came in the dressing room just before the match and he couldn’t even tell his sister beforehand that he was losing, and she did not take it well. I know this sounds silly today over a “fake” wrestling match but it was a different business then. You want to know how much heat Michaels had. In that period, there were two wrestlers I had to talk out of fighting with Michaels (neither of which was Hart, because he and I weren’t on speaking terms at that time), because I told them it wasn’t worth losing your job over, and both were guys who would have been fired in an instant for it. This was well before Hart was leaving.

Most champions of that era under those circumstances would have outright refused to drop the title to a guy who told them to their face twice that they wouldn’t return the favor if asked. Michaels, on the documentary, did say he crossed the line with the “Sunny Days” comment, which was a catalyst for a lot of problems. It was that comment that led to their backstage fight. Michaels, then single, now married, said if someone would have said that on TV about him, he’d have immediately punched them in the mouth.

Levesque’s comments from a 2007 interview were notable because there were all the outright falsehoods in the narrative, the idea Hart’s contract was to expire in Montreal and that he may have gone on Nitro the next day holding the belt if they didn’t beat him that night. He claimed Hart shouldn’t have just vacated the title. And he was right. Given the circumstances of the time, it was imperative to Vince that Hart lose the title in the ring. Hart and his lawyers suggested various options to do so. Not dropping the belt in the ring was never an issue in real life, only one created after the fact to justify the decision.

However, Hart did suggest not dropping the title in the ring hours before the match with Michaels, claiming so much had gotten out in the media, and just handing it over, as Michaels had done the prior February. McMahon agreed, although by that time he’d have agreed to anything Hart said because he was trying to get him to let his guard down. But the wheels were in motion and plan was in place before Hart made that suggestion. At the point the plan was in place, everyone was under the idea that the title change would be in Springfield. But there was a lot of uneasiness just because they were in a wrestling war and their champion had signed a contract with the opposition. Vince wanted it off him immediately and the pressure had caused everyone, from McMahon to Michaels to Hart, to end up at odds with each other. Hart was under contract for more than three weeks after the Montreal match. It only turned out to be his last match because after being double-crossed, he quit. Even though he didn’t come to his bookings the next three weeks, he got paid in full his last $85,000 or so that was still owed.

Bischoff had agreed to let Hart stay an extra week after his contract expired so Hart could drop the title on the following PPV, in Springfield, MA. There was an outstanding lawsuit and it had been established in one case (when Flair used the WCW belt on WWF television in 1991) and there was a legal action going on over a second case (Madusa throwing the WWF women’s belt in a garbage can) to where it was clear a title belt was the company’s intellectual property. There was no possible way at that point in time, that such a scenario could happen. He had a valid WWF contract and the belt was established in court cases as the intellectual property of the promotion, not the temporary property of the champion. Plus, if Hart was to be on Nitro the next day, why wasn’t he on Nitro the next day? If anything, what happened in Montreal should have made it more likely, not less likely, he’d show up there. Even 17 years later, people still use that story that could not have legally happened because if it could have, you think it wouldn’t have?

Even after the contract ended up breached in Montreal, it still didn’t happen, and at that point, you could at least make a legal argument it could have. The reason it didn’t was because he was under WWF contract for several more weeks. Hart didn’t even appear on Nitro until mid-December, even though the quicker he was on Nitro, the better it would have been to capitalize on the Montreal finish. As it played out, it did benefit Hart, except WCW totally dropped the ball on Hart and his value in the Canadian market.

But any study of the Montreal finish that ignores the contract, ignores Michaels refusing to put Hart over, and still pushes the idea that Hart could have showed up with the belt the next night on Nitro is not just showing a WWE bias but being completely dishonest. Vince McMahon was put in a tough situation and as fate would have it, the path he chose benefitted him in the long run, in ways nobody could have ever possibly figured ahead of time. But there were options, and creating the idea that there weren’t any wasn’t true."

Source: The Wrestling Observer Newsletter

.: Join our NEW Wrestling Forum :. 
««« WNS Forum »»»

Tags: #wwe #dave meltzer #bret hart #shawn michaels #screwjob
https://wrestlr.me/36072/  
Adding comments is disabled due to age of article.
 

» More News From This Feed

Apr 06
WWE Monday Night Raw Results (04/06/2020)
The following are the results of the April 6th, 2020 edition of WWE Monday Night Raw: 1. Asuka defeated Liv Morgan 2. Raw Tag Team Champions The Street Profits defeated Angel Garza & Aust[...]
Apr 06 - The following are the results of the April 6th, 2020 edition of WWE Monday Night Raw: 1. Asuka defeated Liv Morgan 2. Raw Tag Team Champions The Street Profits defeated Angel Garza & Aust[...]
Apr 06
WWE Raw Results: Former Raw Women's Champion Returns
During tonight's episode of Raw, former Women's Champion Nia Jax made her return to in-ring competition, picking up a win over NXT Superstar Deonna Purrazzo. JAX. IS. BACK.#WWERaw @N[...]
Apr 06 - During tonight's episode of Raw, former Women's Champion Nia Jax made her return to in-ring competition, picking up a win over NXT Superstar Deonna Purrazzo. JAX. IS. BACK.#WWERaw @N[...]
Apr 06
Another Superstar Switches Brands During Monday Night Raw
In addition to NXT Superstar Bianca Belair officially moving to the Raw roster, SmackDown's Apollo Crews has also been moved to the Raw roster as well. Crews r[...]
Apr 06 - In addition to NXT Superstar Bianca Belair officially moving to the Raw roster, SmackDown's Apollo Crews has also been moved to the Raw roster as well. Crews r[...]
Apr 06
NXT's Bianca Belair Now Seemingly a Member of the Raw Roster
During tonight's episode of Monday Night Raw, Bianca Belair teamed with The Street Profits to take on the trio of Zelina Vega, Angel Garza and Austin Theory. It appears as though Belair has been[...]
Apr 06 - During tonight's episode of Monday Night Raw, Bianca Belair teamed with The Street Profits to take on the trio of Zelina Vega, Angel Garza and Austin Theory. It appears as though Belair has been[...]
Apr 06
WWE Announces that WrestleMania 36 Was the Most Social Event in WWE History
The following comes from WWE.com: This year’s WrestleMania is officially the most social event in WWE history as new champions, a jaw-dropping Boneyard Match, a mind-bending Firefly Fun House[...]
Apr 06 - The following comes from WWE.com: This year’s WrestleMania is officially the most social event in WWE history as new champions, a jaw-dropping Boneyard Match, a mind-bending Firefly Fun House[...]
Apr 06
Official Preview for Tonight's WWE Raw (04/06/2020)
The following matches and segments are confirmed for tonight's Raw, according to WWE.com: The reign of Drew McIntyre begins Where does Edge go from here? Did Kevin Owens end Seth Rollins&rsq[...]
Apr 06 - The following matches and segments are confirmed for tonight's Raw, according to WWE.com: The reign of Drew McIntyre begins Where does Edge go from here? Did Kevin Owens end Seth Rollins&rsq[...]
Apr 06
SmackDown And RAW Next Week Reportedly Going To Be Live From Performance Center
WrestleVotes states that we can expect to see WWE go back to live airing of RAW and SmackDown next week. WWE will be pushing on, and there's no break at this time coming. Tonight's RAW and NXT have b[...]
Apr 06 - WrestleVotes states that we can expect to see WWE go back to live airing of RAW and SmackDown next week. WWE will be pushing on, and there's no break at this time coming. Tonight's RAW and NXT have b[...]
Apr 06
WWE Reveals When Ric Flair Broken Skull Sessions Will Air
Steve Austin’s next Broken Skull Sessions on WWE Network is set to be another big one. WWE has confirmed that Ric Flair’s episode of the Broken Skull Sessions will air this Sunday, April [...]
Apr 06 - Steve Austin’s next Broken Skull Sessions on WWE Network is set to be another big one. WWE has confirmed that Ric Flair’s episode of the Broken Skull Sessions will air this Sunday, April [...]
Apr 06
Edge vs. Randy Orton WrestleMania Match Draws Criticism For Hanging Spot
During the Edge vs. Randy Orton Last Man Standing match at WrestleMania 36 last night there was one spot which has drawn some criticism. During their fight all over the WWE Performance Center, they r[...]
Apr 06 - During the Edge vs. Randy Orton Last Man Standing match at WrestleMania 36 last night there was one spot which has drawn some criticism. During their fight all over the WWE Performance Center, they r[...]
Apr 06
Tampa Bay Still Wants To Host A Future WrestleMania Event
Tampa Bay will be sorely disappointed not to have hosted this past weekend's WWE WrestleMania 36 due to the coronavirus pandemic. Not only was it a huge disappointment for the fans not being able to a[...]
Apr 06 - Tampa Bay will be sorely disappointed not to have hosted this past weekend's WWE WrestleMania 36 due to the coronavirus pandemic. Not only was it a huge disappointment for the fans not being able to a[...]
Apr 06
Michael Cole Receives A Big WWE Promotion
Michael Cole recently received an internal promotion within WWE. PWinsider.com is reporting that the longtime WWE announcer has a new corporate title, Vice President of Announcing. Cole has been inv[...]
Apr 06 - Michael Cole recently received an internal promotion within WWE. PWinsider.com is reporting that the longtime WWE announcer has a new corporate title, Vice President of Announcing. Cole has been inv[...]
Apr 06
CWFH Episode 462: Nikko Marquez signed NWA star
In the Opening contest of this week's Championship Wrestling from Hollywood Episode PP3 Cup Semi-Finalist, Jordan Clearwater defeated the returning Richie Slade via Pinfall after the Golden Boot. Cha[...]
Apr 06 - In the Opening contest of this week's Championship Wrestling from Hollywood Episode PP3 Cup Semi-Finalist, Jordan Clearwater defeated the returning Richie Slade via Pinfall after the Golden Boot. Cha[...]
Apr 06
Drew McIntyre Says He Wants To Bring Pay Per View To The UK
New WWE Champion Drew McIntyre has revealed his intentions to bring a Pay Per View back to the UK following his WrestleMania 36 victory.  On the second night of this year's unprecedented Wrestle[...]
Apr 06 - New WWE Champion Drew McIntyre has revealed his intentions to bring a Pay Per View back to the UK following his WrestleMania 36 victory.  On the second night of this year's unprecedented Wrestle[...]
Apr 06
Who Booked The Firefly Fun House Match At WrestleMania 36?
Dave Meltzer revealed on Wrestling Observer Radio that Bruce Prichard, Bray Wyatt, and John Cena were the three people most responsible for the creative booking of the Firefly Fun House match at last [...]
Apr 06 - Dave Meltzer revealed on Wrestling Observer Radio that Bruce Prichard, Bray Wyatt, and John Cena were the three people most responsible for the creative booking of the Firefly Fun House match at last [...]
Apr 06
Superfan Reveals WWE Almost Considered Fans At WrestleMania 36
Many WWE fans have WrestleMania streaks for the number of Mania's they have attended over the years, but maybe none bigger than Chris Adorno, known as Ringside Charlie who has attended every WrestleMa[...]
Apr 06 - Many WWE fans have WrestleMania streaks for the number of Mania's they have attended over the years, but maybe none bigger than Chris Adorno, known as Ringside Charlie who has attended every WrestleMa[...]
Apr 06
Becky Lynch's WrestleMania 36 Victory Made Some History
As seen this weekend, Becky Lynch defended the WWE Raw Women’s Championship in the main event of WrestleMania 36 Night One, defeating Shayna Baszler to retain the Title. The WWE Stats & Inf[...]
Apr 06 - As seen this weekend, Becky Lynch defended the WWE Raw Women’s Championship in the main event of WrestleMania 36 Night One, defeating Shayna Baszler to retain the Title. The WWE Stats & Inf[...]
Apr 06
WWE To Tape Post-WrestleMania 36 Episode Of SmackDown From A Secret Location?
As previously reported, WWE taped WrestleMania 36, Raw, NXT after WrestleMania last week at the Performance Center prior to the stay at home order in Florida. This poses a problem as the company will[...]
Apr 06 - As previously reported, WWE taped WrestleMania 36, Raw, NXT after WrestleMania last week at the Performance Center prior to the stay at home order in Florida. This poses a problem as the company will[...]
Apr 05
WWE WrestleMania 36 Night 2 Results (04/05/2020)
The following are the results of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36: 1. Charlotte Flair defeated Rhea Ripley to become the new NXT Women's Champion 2. Aleister Black defeated Bobby Lashley 3. Otis D[...]
Apr 05 - The following are the results of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36: 1. Charlotte Flair defeated Rhea Ripley to become the new NXT Women's Champion 2. Aleister Black defeated Bobby Lashley 3. Otis D[...]
Apr 05
WWE WrestleMania 36 Results: Brock Lesnar vs. Drew McIntyre: WWE Championship Match
In the main event of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, "The Scottish Psychopath" Drew McIntyre defeated "The Beast Incarnate" Brock Lesnar for the WWE Championship after four Claymore Kicks. .@DMcIn[...]
Apr 05 - In the main event of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, "The Scottish Psychopath" Drew McIntyre defeated "The Beast Incarnate" Brock Lesnar for the WWE Championship after four Claymore Kicks. .@DMcIn[...]
Apr 05
WWE WrestleMania 36 Results: John Cena vs. Bray Wyatt: Firefly Fun House Match
In the co-main event of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, "The Fiend" Bray Wyatt defeated 16-time WWE World Champion John Cena in the Firefly Fun House Match. Welcome to MɹƎS┴˥ƎW∀NI&for[...]
Apr 05 - In the co-main event of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, "The Fiend" Bray Wyatt defeated 16-time WWE World Champion John Cena in the Firefly Fun House Match. Welcome to MɹƎS┴˥ƎW∀NI&for[...]
Apr 05
WWE WrestleMania 36 Results: SmackDown Women's Title 5-Way Elimination Match
The historic championship title reign of Bayley continued at Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, as she outlasted Lacey Evans, Naomi, Tamina Snuka and Sasha Banks in a Five-Way Elimination Match to retai[...]
Apr 05 - The historic championship title reign of Bayley continued at Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, as she outlasted Lacey Evans, Naomi, Tamina Snuka and Sasha Banks in a Five-Way Elimination Match to retai[...]
Apr 05
WWE WrestleMania 36 Results: Street Profits vs. Garza & Theory: Raw Tag Team Title Match
The Street Profits successfully defended their Raw Tag Team Championships at WrestleMania 36 against the team of Angel Garza and Austin Theory. After the match, NXT Superstar Bianca Belair m[...]
Apr 05 - The Street Profits successfully defended their Raw Tag Team Championships at WrestleMania 36 against the team of Angel Garza and Austin Theory. After the match, NXT Superstar Bianca Belair m[...]
Apr 05
Rob Gronkowski Wins 24/7 Championship at WrestleMania 36
Rob Gronkowski captured his first WWE championship during Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, as he defeated Mojo Rawley to become the new 24/7 Champion. Quite literally diving into the #247Title pict[...]
Apr 05 - Rob Gronkowski captured his first WWE championship during Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, as he defeated Mojo Rawley to become the new 24/7 Champion. Quite literally diving into the #247Title pict[...]
Apr 05
WWE WrestleMania 36 Results: Edge vs. Randy Orton: Last Man Standing Match
In his first WrestleMania match in nearly a decade, WWE Hall of Famer Edge defeated "The Viper" Randy Orton in a brutal Last Man Standing Match during Night 2 of WrestleMania 36. [...]
Apr 05 - In his first WrestleMania match in nearly a decade, WWE Hall of Famer Edge defeated "The Viper" Randy Orton in a brutal Last Man Standing Match during Night 2 of WrestleMania 36. [...]
Apr 05
WWE WrestleMania 36 Results: Otis Dozovic vs. Dolph Ziggler (w/ Sonya Deville)
In the third match of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, Otis Dozovic of Heavy Machinery defeated former two-time World Heavyweight Champion Dolph Ziggler with some help from Mandy Rose. "Cute"? Mayb[...]
Apr 05 - In the third match of Night 2 of WrestleMania 36, Otis Dozovic of Heavy Machinery defeated former two-time World Heavyweight Champion Dolph Ziggler with some help from Mandy Rose. "Cute"? Mayb[...]

© 2006-2020 wrestlingnewssource.com

All rights reserved. All other trademarks, logos, video, likeness and copyrights are the property of their respective owners.
Terms of Service · Privacy Policy · Π