WARNING:We have detected your browser is out of date. For both performance, security and a better web experience you should keep up to date to avoid viruses, malware, hijacking and stay on top of compatibility features.
This year’s Bound for Glory divided fans like no other show I’ve seen this year. Depending on who you asked, you’d think that TNA’s biggest event of the year was either the physical manifestation of a rapacious Nazi who’d snorted the ashes of your dead children and desecrated your parent’s grave, or a unicorn farting rainbows and sunshine. But which was it? Was Bound for Glory a good event? And could it even be considered better than WrestleMania 29?
Personally, I thought it was a good show; it had good and bad moments, but it was mostly good. From the aftermath of Bound For Glory rose an interesting discussion in the FTW community: ‘Was Bound For Glory a better show than Wrestlemania?’.
How exactly does one determine what makes a good Pay Per View event? Due to the gulf in the respective fan bases of TNA and the WWE, one cannot judge based on attendance or buy rates. Instead, a dissection of the cards in question is required. My approach takes three forms: the variety of wrestling, the timing of the show, and a direct comparison of the main events.
Firstly, we can look at the variety of wrestling throughout Bound For Glory and Wrestlemania, respectively. One of the things I hope we can agree on is that everyone’s tastes are different. What may entertain one fan will not entertain another; some like technical wrestling, some like lucha libre, and part of what makes a great show is a variety of styles. In this respect, Bound For Glory beat Wrestlemania to a bloody pulp. If you are a fan of high flying wrestling, you were catered to with the Ultimate X match that opened the card. Fans of technical wrestling would have enjoyed Bobby Roode and Kurt Angle’s show-stealing performances. Tag Team fans had enjoyable encounters in the pre-show and the Bro Mans subsequent title win on the main show. If you were a fan of hardcore wrestling, the main event delivered in spades with a hard-hitting No Disqualification match between AJ Styles and Bully Ray. Female wrestling fans were also treated to Lei’d Tapa’s continued domination of the Knockouts division as she helped Gail Kim to a third Knockouts Title. Wrestlemania, however, provided a hardcore match in Brock Lesnar versus Triple H and a lacklustre tag team match between Team Hell No and the team of Dolph Ziggler and Big E Langston.
Matt Kodner of the AV Club sums Wrestlemania up well, saying it was “too much of the same, with nary a sense of fun to the matches.”
In fact, we can clearly see a discrepancy between the pure variety of wrestling on show at Bound For Glory and Wrestlemania. That is not all that we can take into consideration when judging the two events, either. We can also look at the fact that all but one of TNA’s titles were defended at Bound For Glory; in comparison, at Wrestlemania, only four were defended (Intercontinental, Tag Team, World Heavyweight and WWE), leaving the Divas and US titles unmentioned and the women’s division ignored completely.
Additionally, the timing of Wrestlemania was a complete mess. It is no secret; in fact, it was one of the big criticisms of the show. The mixed team tag match with Tons of Funk and the Funkadactyls versus Team Rhodes Scholars and the Bellas got cut from the card during the show due to time constraints. The timing issues also caused the main event to suffer with the Rock and John Cena being given more time than was originally planned. As a result they had to improvise and the match descended into a cacophony of finishing moves with very little variety or substance. Additionally, because the 8 person tag team match was pulled, there was no cool down match. The Jersey crowd was exhausted after the excellence of CM Punk’s attempt to end the Undertaker’s streak, and as a result, they were not as responsive to the HHH and Brock Lesnar match that followed. This led to less of an atmosphere and negatively impacted what was actually a great match. Bound For Glory, on the other hand, was a fairly well-oiled machine; even Ethan Carter III was given a decent amount of time in his squashing of Norv Fernum. One match flowed into the other, and cool-down matches were well placed; after the crowd wore themselves out, they were able to recover, and suspense and tension rose at a steady rate as the night went on.
A direct comparison of the respective main events also demonstrates how Bound For Glory outdid Wrestlemania. There are similar themes running through each match, with the young face of the company taking on an older more experienced guy (there is only one year’s difference between The Rock at 41 and Bully Ray at 42), but the similarities end there. AJ and Bully Ray delivered superb tension, brutal reality and several memorable high spots, whilst the Rock and John Cena simply traded finishers like I did Pokemon cards in the schoolyard. The two seconds when AJ leapt off the ring apron and delivered a 450 splash through the announcers’ table was more enjoyable and breath-taking than all four Rock Bottoms and three Attitude Adjustments in Wrestlemania’s main event.
To sum up, a greater variety of styles of wrestling, better timing and a main event that was head and shoulders above the Wrestlemania equivalent means that Bound For Glory 2013 was the better show. Better balance, more excitement, better structure, and a superior build-up lay the cards firmly in TNA’s hands in the battle of the biggest shows of the year.
Nov 16 - All Elite Wrestling star Dustin Rhodes posted the following on Twitter: Tuesday night catch me on #AEWDark as I am guest commentator. Y'all let me know how I did. Great exciting show. My personal p[...]
Nov 16 - As was previously reported, the WWE 2K Facebook page was recently hacked and inappropriate posts were sent out on the page. 2K has since regained control of the page and issued an apology for the post[...]
WWE 205 Live/NXT Superstar Requests His Release According to a report from PWInsider.com, WWE Superstar Oney Lorcan has requested his release from WWE. There are no details as to why exactly he has requested his release, although it should be note[...]
Nov 16 - According to a report from PWInsider.com, WWE Superstar Oney Lorcan has requested his release from WWE. There are no details as to why exactly he has requested his release, although it should be note[...]
Nov 16 - This week's episode of WWE Friday Night SmackDown on FOX drew an average of 2.35 million viewers, according to F4WOnline.com/The Wrestling Observer Newsletter. The first hour drew 2.445 mill[...]
Nov 16 - Many don't realize that Bobby Lashley is still signed with Bellator MMA despite being a part of WWE currently. Lashley is 15-2 in his MMA career with his last fight in October 2016. He's made t[...]
Nov 16 - WWE officially announced the event on Twitter today, also noting it will again take place in The Empress Ballroom and tickets will go on sale this Monday at 10 am GMT (5 am ET). Since the news broke,[...]
Nov 16 - JR recently spoke with WFNZ/RADIO.COM about a variety of subjects. At one point, he was asked who the best wingman was in all of pro wrestling, and without any hesitation he stated Ric Flair. [...]
Nov 16 - The Infinite Energy Center in Duluth, Georgia has announced a new main event for the upcoming 2019 WWE Starrcade live event, which will take place on Sunday, December 1st. The event will be head[...]
2K Games Issues Statement Regarding Ongoing Hacking As previously reported, a hacker commenced a cyber attack Friday night on some of the social media accounts of 2K Games, including WWE 2K. As part of the attack, the hacker posted material of both a s[...]
Nov 16 - As previously reported, a hacker commenced a cyber attack Friday night on some of the social media accounts of 2K Games, including WWE 2K. As part of the attack, the hacker posted material of both a s[...]
WWE Tried To Help ACH With His Issues Earlier this week ACH aka Jordan Myles announced he was quitting WWE. His decision to quit comes weeks after the company released a shirt that was deemed racially insensitive. ACH then vented his frus[...]
Nov 16 - Earlier this week ACH aka Jordan Myles announced he was quitting WWE. His decision to quit comes weeks after the company released a shirt that was deemed racially insensitive. ACH then vented his frus[...]
Jacob Fatu Signs New Deal With MLW MLW announced that World Heavyweight Champion Jacob Fatu has signed a new multi-year contract with the company. According to PWInsider, as part of the new deal MLW will have control over bookin[...]
Nov 16 - MLW announced that World Heavyweight Champion Jacob Fatu has signed a new multi-year contract with the company. According to PWInsider, as part of the new deal MLW will have control over bookin[...]
Nov 16 - WWE will make their return to Madison Square Garden on December 26th, and new matches were just announced for the house show. Here’s what fans can expect at the event: Seth Rollins[...]
WWE To Start Granting Releases Earlier this week, WWE star Sin Cara announced on Twitter that he was asking for his release from the company. Sin Cara is just one of may WWE wrestlers who’ve expressed frustration with the com[...]
Nov 15 - Earlier this week, WWE star Sin Cara announced on Twitter that he was asking for his release from the company. Sin Cara is just one of may WWE wrestlers who’ve expressed frustration with the com[...]
Nov 15 - Courtesy of WrestlingObserver.com, here are tonight's Friday Night SmackDown results: The build to Survivor Series continues as Friday Night SmackDown takes place from the Wells Fargo Center in Phila[...]
Nov 15 - Tonight on Facebook you may have noticed something up with the official WWE 2K page. It seemingly has been hacked with the hacker putting out a number of inappropriate posts, such as "WWE IS FAKE", r[...]
Nov 15 - Nick Jackson will be competing in a singles match against the Lucha Bros Rey Fenix on this Wednesday's AEW Dynamite in Indianapolis. His brother, Matt Jackson has not been cleared to compete due to l[...]
Nov 15 - WWE NXT Superstar Boa has revealed on social media that he recently underwent surgery this week to repair an injured shoulder. Boa dropped posted on Instagram: “What did happen was 3Weeks ag[...]
Another WWE Title Belt Receiving A New Look WWE on Friday's SmackDown revealed a new design for Bray Wyatt’s Universal Championship. The belt changed from red to blue, it made sense considering Wyatt is a SmackDown exclusive. @WrestleVot[...]
Nov 15 - WWE on Friday's SmackDown revealed a new design for Bray Wyatt’s Universal Championship. The belt changed from red to blue, it made sense considering Wyatt is a SmackDown exclusive. @WrestleVot[...]
Nov 15 - The WWE Universal Title is now BLUE! “The Fiend” Bray Wyatt hosted a special edition of Firefly Fun House on tonight’s SmackDown on FOX and revealed the new look title belt. The de[...]
Another Spoiler For Tonight's WWE SmackDown The NXT invasion looks set to continue tonight on WWE Friday Night SmackDown in Philadelphia, PA. PWInsider reported earlier that all four members of The Undisputed Era are backstage tonight's SmackD[...]
Nov 15 - The NXT invasion looks set to continue tonight on WWE Friday Night SmackDown in Philadelphia, PA. PWInsider reported earlier that all four members of The Undisputed Era are backstage tonight's SmackD[...]
Nov 15 - Brian Kendrick has announced on Twitter he will be taking a leave of absence from the ring due to frustrations with his current role within the company. He tweeted: "It’s been 3 years since m[...]